Sign in or 

|
2ill4u |
40. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 7:38 PM EST
"I agree... Most excellent points.if you are talking about TSCC storyline to find coexistence with the machines, I agree, it seems that is where the writers might take us, but i think skynet will still happen it might just be a little more friendly. Do you find this valuable? |
|
tommy-minou |
41. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 7:39 PM EST
Thanks THX-1138 - I agree that this forum is swamped with shippers, and, basically people treating TSCC like a soap opera. As though they don't really think that hard about it. With Skynet preparing and building - yes it seems that the future keeps getting racheted up again and again by interventions in the 'now' - but really Skynet does need to be getting all its hardware together before JD, it's a bit like Germany in the late 1930s - they're tooling up! ViperX883 also made an interesting point about John Henry that it needs to learn to value human life, so it can learn to value its own, so it can go ahead and develop an ego and become a self-seeking, self-interested meglomaniac. One counter-idea to that is that Skynet is actually an amalgam of a load of computers across the internet - almost like a giant ghost living in cyberspace - and it doesn't have an 'ego', it's like a collective consciousness, which decides that man is getting in the way of its progress. If that's the case then maybe John Henry is a prototype Terminator, not the prototype Skynet. Now there's no episodes until Feb, I'm worried that this forum is going to descend into wilder and dumber speculation about John and Cameron (yawn). I'll start putting up OT threads like 'what's your favorite color' just to get away from tedious shippers. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
TerminTatorTot |
42. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 7:39 PM EST
All good discussions. I still think Weaver is on our side. Benevolent Terminators of the John Henry kind. Look at the symbolism the writers are giving us. The name John Henry is from a legend of a human that challenged machines. Ellison will basically instill in John Henry the Three Laws of Robotics (from Isaac Asimov "Foundation" series of science fiction books). The aircraft at the end of "Earthlings..." was a Zeira Corp. creation I'd say.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
DeusEx |
43. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 7:40 PM EST
Anyway, Skynet didn't seem to need morality lessons before, so Weaver is trying something new here.I was always of the thought that Weaver is trying for a competitor to Skynet, and the various bendable and Ellison termies were sent back by Skynet, to stop her. Maybe Skynet thought Weaver was trying for a warmer, fuzzier version of itself. Or, maybe it was simply scared of being replaced by a beefed up version. On morality making Skynet beefier, its an interesting idea. I don't agree it needs it for sentience (my kids are sentient....nuff said!), but possible it gives it greater understanding of humans or something. I don't know, I really can't make any sense out of it yet. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
DeusEx |
44. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 7:44 PM EST
"All good discussions. I still think Weaver is on our side. Benevolent Terminators of the John Henry kind. Look at the symbolism the writers are giving us. The name John Henry is from a legend of a human that challenged machines. Ellison will basically instill in John Henry the Three Laws of Robotics (from Isaac Asimov "Foundation" series of science fiction books). The aircraft at the end of "Earthlings..." was a Zeira Corp. creation I'd say."I agree that the evidence seems to support that, that Weaver is on our side and is good. I just find it hard to believe that the T-1000 would not be an adversary! C'mon, no showdown with Cameron? And whats with all the gratuitous killing if Weaver isn't evil? Its why she is such a mystery. Being good, or being evil, just doesn't seem to fit entirely. Do you find this valuable? |
|
tommy-minou |
45. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 8:05 PM EST
"I agree that the evidence seems to support that, that Weaver is on our side and is good. I just find it hard to believe that the T-1000 would not be an adversary! C'mon, no showdown with Cameron? And whats with all the gratuitous killing if Weaver isn't evil?Hang on the evidence is that Weaver has murdered a few people earlier on - including the woman she replaced and her husband. The evidence is that Weaver is beginning to learn to not be more human, but there's almost no info about what she is really up to - Zeira corp is what Cyberdyne used to be - eg the company who plays midwife to Skynet - but is there anything pointing at the theory that she is trying to make a 'nicer' Skynet? 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
TerminTatorTot |
46. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 8:28 PM EST
"Hang on the evidence is that Weaver has murdered a few people earlier on - including the woman she replaced and her husband. The evidence is that Weaver is beginning to learn to not be more human, but there's almost no info about what she is really up to - Zeira corp is what Cyberdyne used to be - eg the company who plays midwife to Skynet - but is there anything pointing at the theory that she is trying to make a 'nicer' Skynet?"The evidence we see in the show says Weaver is working with Ellison to give John Henry ethics, and nothing she has done says she is working for Skynet. Also, her name might have ended up on the bloody wall if she was a baddie. Do you find this valuable? |
|
SAABMaven |
47. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 8:56 PM EST
"I think I might have to find a new place to discuss Terminator. I want to discuss deep philosophical implications of the storyline, but this clearly isn't the place to do it.... while I receive zero response to the central theme and development in the storyline of this series. Yeah, I think it speaks for itself."Sorry, I just finished watching Episode 13 about ten minutes ago. I don't own a TV and only manage to pick up an episode when I go out to work, back on the grid. Your comments are insightful and I will just have to think about them before replying. Do you find this valuable? |
|
SAABMaven |
48. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 9:03 PM EST
"I'm smelling a closet Randian."Kant, actually. :) Alyssa Rosenbaum was a very smart girl. Do you find this valuable? |
|
SAABMaven |
49. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 9:08 PM EST
Perhaps we should be thinking not 'good' and 'evil' but good & bad; as in good for me and bad for me. Is a wrecked planet the best option for Skynet? Humans as nothing but malhourished slaves in camps? Hardly constructive, and they wouldn't play good chess.Does this make me a 'closet Nietzsche-ist' ? :) 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Talon_Svarog |
50. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 9:26 PM EST
Oh, goody, finally one of the threads that actually give meaning to this site :)Now, where where we. Oh yes, Skynet sending back Terminators to complete specific tasks that will benefit it in the future, etc etc. Strangely enough, this is similar to a theory that I came up with a few weeks ago regarding the War against the Machines as a temporal conflict. First, a bit of speculation/fact on how time travel has affected the original timeline, putting us into the present version of the timeline, which could be altered countless times before JD (if it happens). Facts: 1. The origin of skynet has changed at least two times in the Terminator timeline, first due to Cyberdyne being destroyed, and second due to Andy Goode being shot. 2. Both Skynet and the Resistance are known to be screwing around with the timeline to make it better for their side in the war, i.e Skynet trying to kill John Connor, and the Resistance sending back people to kill Skynet. Speculation: 1. The timeline may have been altered several times in TSCC, not including killing Andy Goode. It is possible that Catherine Weaver, Jesse/Riley, the guy who wrote in blood/Greenway Terminator, Fischer and the Ellison Terminator are all from different timelines, each one created by present actions. 2. Catherine Weaver may not have been sent back by Skynet, but instead could be a reprogrammed Terminator sent back by Connor to create a more peaceful version of Skynet, one that values human life as a contingency plan in case Skynet can not be killed before JD. This is based on the fact that Connor knows from experience that you can teach a machine to value human life, like he did with 'Uncle Bob' in T2. 3. The Flying Machine is a HK built by a company that is being run by a Terminator with the purpose to start construction of Skynets machine army pre-JD. Do you find this valuable? |
|
DeusEx |
51. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 9:32 PM EST
"Kant, actually. :) Alyssa Rosenbaum was a very smart girl."Yes, she was. A little on the nutty side, like many geniuses. Do you find this valuable? |
|
Talon_Svarog |
52. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 9:35 PM EST
My theory is that sometime in the future both Skynet and John Connor come to the realization that they can not prevent the other from being born/existing in the future, despite numerous attempts to succeed in that plan. Any attempt to kill John Connor ends in failure, and any attempt to stop Skynet from being born ends in failure. Therefore, both of them decide to send back agents, Terminators for Skynet and Resistance fighters for Connor, back in time to prepare for the war.Skynet: 1. Terminators set up robotics companies. 2. These companies produce different forms of HKs and Terminators. With all the future information, it is just a matter of having people produce basic versions of the machines and slowly upgrade them to their future versions. These machines can then be mass produced in the present, allowing Skynet to release them after JD, or use them to destroy the human race without resorting to a nuclear apocalypse. Resistance: Resistance fighters and reprogrammed Terminators are sent back in time with specific missions, each one will assist in jump starting the resistance within hours to days of JD happening. Set up supply dumps, bunkers, and possibly even design and build plasma weaponry(the latter being highly unlikely). Some could even be sent back in time to do other things such as build missile defence systems to stop JD, or to simply set up resistance cells pre-JD so they can start fighting back post-JD. Weaver: She's anyone's guess. Either she is here to protect Skynet, and ensure its birth, or she is here to ensure the birth of a more humane version of Skynet, that will not decide to wipe out the human race. A more far fetched theory is that she was sent back to build an AI that would oppose Skynet, and destroy it before it can trigger JD. This draws on the John Henry legend, a man opposing progress and despite emerging victorious, still losing his own life. Do you find this valuable? |
|
Talon_Svarog |
53. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 9:36 PM EST
"Yes, she was. A little on the nutty side, like many geniuses."Thanks for breaking up my two posts with something useless :P 0 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
disasterpiece73 |
54. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 10:44 PM EST
"I think I might have to find a new place to discuss Terminator. I want to discuss deep philosophical implications of the storyline, but this clearly isn't the place to do it. For example, someone makes a thread about Cameron's smoothie line around the same time as I make this one and the smoothie thread is already two pages in length. So, two pages about a freaking smoothie while I receive zero response to the central theme and development in the storyline of this series. Yeah, I think it speaks for itself."You're not the only one, THX. I'm growing wary of the shippers and the general meanness that some of the other posters engage conversation about, too. I've been a Sci-Fi fan for a long time and I've never seen the level of immaturity that I've encountered here. Kind of makes me wish we had a killfile function like there was on usenet back in the day, but that only reinforces the fact that this place is literally infested with people who are prone to trollish behavior. It also reminds me that I'm a lot older than the fanbase of the show at the same time. Just try to ignore the shippers and keep the intelligent dialogue going, with any luck, the smoothie inspired threads will be buried by the people who actually want to engage in intelligent conversation with other fans. 4 out of 4 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
trigger_happy14 |
55. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 11:01 PM EST
THX, I'm really glad you brought this up.If it weren't for this main theme the whole episode would have been quite meaningless. Skynet is definitely going on the offensive in the past in a much more widespread and strategic manner rather than the simple "kill John Connor" motive that seemed to always be the answer to Skynet's victory. I don't think killing John Connor is going to be enough to win the war anymore, hence the reason for so many individual targets and so many Terminators being sent back. On the topic of immature posts, this is a TV show forum. Like it or not, not all the posts are gonna be full of philosophical and deep meanings. That's just how the internet is unfortunately. However, sometimes, threads such as that Smoothie thread mentioned earlier are created purely for fun. Sometimes people just want to play around and talk about the little funny things about an episode. It doesn't all have to be serious... :( 3 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
TerminTatorTot |
56. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 11:09 PM EST
"THX, I'm really glad you brought this up.thanks trigger_happy14. It is fun to just do to silly threads at times like smoothies or others. I think you are wrong about the "widespread and strategic" Skynet strategy. Much of what you see in the recent episodes is all Catherine Weaver based, not Skynet. We'll see, of course. Do you find this valuable? |
|
trigger_happy14 |
57. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 11:17 PM EST
"thanks trigger_happy14. It is fun to just do to silly threads at times like smoothies or others.Huh, well I wasn't really thinking about Weaver mainly because we really just don't KNOW anything about her intentions yet. I mean the "John sent her back" theory moderately makes sense, but I can't really buy it unless we have more proof. For one thing, I don't see how the Resistance could've gotten their hands on such an advanced model. I mean she's not even a T-1000, she's a T-1001 (whatever THAT means). Somehow I don't see that the writers are gonna go the Battlestar Galactica route and make this a story about how machines and humans can leave peacefully together. Skynet has always been a ruthless enemy that has never had an intention to coincide with humans. Maybe after Skynet is destroyed, but DEFINITELY not before. I doubt it can be reasoned with. Well... we'll see I guess. Do you find this valuable? |
|
tinear |
58. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 16 2008, 11:55 PM EST
"Huh, well I wasn't really thinking about Weaver mainly because we really just don't KNOW anything about her intentions yet.Couple of thoughts: 1. While the "Can't we all just get along to avoid JD" theory is intriguing, I just don't buy it, for the simple reason that this IS a TV show that needs RATINGS, which means maintaining a Keep it Simple Stupid format -- or at least SHOULD maintain it. (See Lost, Heroes, etc for shows that lost their way). Basically, the producers/writers can't afford to go too far off the map or risk losing fringe followers (as opposed to Fringe followers) :o) 2. Because of reason No. 1, I think what we're watching is a more standard buildup to JD; a pre-quel to the movies. Can't say I'd mind it not being that, but I also would enjoy the more traditional route. If I want something deeper ... I'll read a book. 3. Because of reason No. 1 and No. 2, I see John Henry as "learning" about human emotion as a way to use it against humans after JD. Again, a more traditional story line has JH "gaining" emotion, which explains how he could become "scared" enough to force JD. 4. Weaver is indeed a curiosity. I keep going back to her "cross against the light" comment. Does she want to create a version of Term that thinks independently? Maybe ... but she ALREADY thinks independently, so what's up with that. Unless of course she herself is a product (in the future) of having created a Term (in the past) that allows her to "cross against the light." 2 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jrockblast |
59. RE: Don't overlook the central theme of episode 13
Dec 17 2008, 12:30 AM EST
"We've known about John Connor's ability to send people back in time for the resistance, and we've even seen this season how other rogue human interests can make it back as well. This latest episode cements the notion that Skynet is -also- fully capable of changing the dynamics of the future and is actively pursuing altering its course. Skynet too is following the "no fate" storyline and building drones NOW, beefing up John Henry NOW, all in an effort to gain the advantage even before or without a so-called Judgement Day."man im very much an adult but sometimes I think people get way too serious it's all entertainment people have free will to post what they think feel etc.. whether u think its juenville or not 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |