Location: Terminator: Sarah Connor Chronicles Discussion Forum

Discussion: Toni Graphia on Derek's DeathReported This is a featured thread

Showing 161 - 178 of 178  |  Show  posts at a time
First < Previous | 6 7 8 9

jht53
160. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 4:47 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 4:48 PM EDT
I think the way Derek's death had been written was one of the things JF got right over the course of the series. Not only was it shocking, but that moment solidified that TSCC was far more than just a standard fare television show. As for Toni Graphia, she should've been the head writer of the show. AFP was definitely the highpoint of TSCC. Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
161. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 5:31 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 5:31 PM EDT
"Suddenly shifting into so called realism in a show that didn't really respect realism is incongruent. For example, what Hyperalloy mentioned about the 9mm ;-) I used to manufacture bullets for a time, a long time ago, mainly 9mm. A 9mm bullet will kill a person well enough but has no where near the power needed to even effect something made of thick hard metal. If they were suppose to be in a state of preparedness all the time, I never understood why they even carried these 9mm guns around. They may as well have been throwing spit balls at the terminators. They could have at least upgraded their hand guns to something like a 44 magnum.

Any ways, running at killer robot with a 9 mm is basically suicide. He would have been more effective if he had snuck up behind the terminator and pulled his pants down. At least then, the terminator might have tripped over his pants and giving Derek enough time to run away."
Lol, I'm still laughing about Derek pulling the Water Boy's pants down and running away...
Hey, SurfingEagle.

The sad part is that it's absolutely true. I always shake my head when I see them walking around with 9mm's. Seriously, they might as well be firing water guns if you're talking Terminators. 9mm can be stopped with half-decent body armor let alone a Terminator's hyperalloy combat chassis. Really no handgun will do, well anything, to a Terminator, but .40 to .45 caliber rounds would have been a lot more believable. In the pilot, when Cromartie scanned the SWAT team's weapons, most of them were carrying MP5's, which fire 9mm rounds. He classified them as having zero threat level lol. So naturally, Sarah and the crew walk around with 9mm all the time...

Really though, I think of that as a problem with the series as a whole, rather than that scene. Otherwise, I liked the realism factor. I didn't like that they killed Derek, of course, but please, no Hollywood death scenes.
Do you find this valuable?    
SurfingEagle
SurfingEagle
162. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 6:12 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 6:12 PM EDT
"Really though, I think of that as a problem with the series as a whole, rather than that scene. Otherwise, I liked the realism factor. I didn't like that they killed Derek, of course, but please, no Hollywood death scenes."
I still never got it. I mean Riley has this dramatic battle to the death with Jesse, and it seems most people didn't like the Riley character much. I thought that was one of the better fights in the series. Then, Derek, a popular character, gets wasted with no fuss. I'm over it now, but hey, there's not much left to talk about on this site anymore.
Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
163. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 6:34 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 6:34 PM EDT
"I still never got it. I mean Riley has this dramatic battle to the death with Jesse, and it seems most people didn't like the Riley character much. I thought that was one of the better fights in the series. Then, Derek, a popular character, gets wasted with no fuss. I'm over it now, but hey, there's not much left to talk about on this site anymore."
Lol, I was definitely one of the many Riley haters, and was looking forward to her death (I saw it coming a mile away), right up until the end that is. I still don't like the character and am glad she's gone, but you're right, her fight at the end was fantastic, second only to the various Terminator fights. The writers definitely did their job on that scene, at least with this viewer that is. I hated the character, but at the same time, I was actually a little sad that she lost the fight after doing so well. She definitely didn't go quietly into that good night. Until Jesse got the gun, I'd have called the fight for Riley. About the only time I liked Riley.

You've got a point about the disparity there. Derek might have gotten a raw deal there considering what Riley got. Of course, but that wasn't the first time they didn't exactly do a character justice in the peril department. The Cameron car bomb was the first, imo. Seriously, a shard from a car bomb penetrates what's probably the most heavily armored portion of her endoskeleton? A gas truck exploded in T1 and the T-800, a less advanced model, only lost it's skin, no real damage to the endoskelton, let alone the chip. Plot-driven events at the expense of realism strikes again.



Do you find this valuable?    
SurfingEagle
SurfingEagle
164. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 7:00 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 7:00 PM EDT
"Lol, I was definitely one of the many Riley haters, and was looking forward to her death (I saw it coming a mile away), right up until the end that is. I still don't like the character and am glad she's gone, but you're right, her fight at the end was fantastic, second only to the various Terminator fights. "
I'm getting a little off topic but I thought the Riley/Jesse fight was second only to the Cromartie ambush, IMO. And yeah, if it wasn't for that damn Riley, John and Cameron might have made it to first base. ;-) Poor Riley. Nobody likes her. I'll be her fan.
Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
165. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 7:33 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 7:36 PM EDT
"I'm getting a little off topic but I thought the Riley/Jesse fight was second only to the Cromartie ambush, IMO. And yeah, if it wasn't for that damn Riley, John and Cameron might have made it to first base. ;-) Poor Riley. Nobody likes her. I'll be her fan."
Yes, Damn Riley! Then on to second base, and third... Oh well, Jameron won in the end anyway lol. And being off-topic is fun.

Personally, my favorite is the safe house fight in the second episode, but the Cromartie ambush was definitely up there for me. The Pilot's one of my favorite episodes, in fact.

Lol, her one and only fan. :p

Do you find this valuable?    
SurfingEagle
SurfingEagle
166. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 8:01 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 8:01 PM EDT
"Yes, Damn Riley! Then on to second base, and third... Oh well, Jameron won in the end anyway lol. And being off-topic is fun.

Personally, my favorite is the safe house fight in the second episode, but the Cromartie ambush was definitely up there for me. The Pilot's one of my favorite episodes, in fact.

Lol, her one and only fan. :p

"
Oh, I forgot about the fight with Cameron and that other female cyborg. That may have tied with the Riley/Jesse fight. But my favorite episode is still probably ep1 of s2. I liked the music and the way Summer did her expressions in that fight, and then Cameron getting all emotional at the end freaked me out. Then, John pulling a gun on his family to save Cameron. So many different things going on in that episode.

and lol, if there's a TSCC convention and Leven Rambin is there and I attend, at least the line for autographs will be short.

Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
167. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 8:22 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 8:23 PM EDT
"Oh, I forgot about the fight with Cameron and that other female cyborg. That may have tied with the Riley/Jesse fight. But my favorite episode is still probably ep1 of s2. I liked the music and the way Summer did her expressions in that fight, and then Cameron getting all emotional at the end freaked me out. Then, John pulling a gun on his family to save Cameron. So many different things going on in that episode.

and lol, if there's a TSCC convention and Leven Rambin is there and I attend, at least the line for autographs will be short.

"
Lol, that boy staring up at Cameron and the other female Terminator was so funny, and you're right, that fight was easily one of the better ones. There's nothing like watching Cameron dominate. I also really liked the fight in "Automatic for People" where Cameron and Sarah teamed up and took down the Greenway T-888. Sarah set him up, and Cameron came in with the take down. And while it's not exactly a fight, Cromartie's whole plan and its execution during "The Mousetrap" was masterfully done. He outsmarted Sarah and Derek there.

And "Samson and Delilah" easily ranks as my favorite, with the pilot coming in second. That one's got it all, action, tragedy, grief, excitement, anticipation, romance, and everything in between. Cameron's emotional outburst scene and John saving her after are easily my favorite scenes of the series. That was so freaky too; there's been a lot of times where I've tried putting myself in John's position there, and I seriously don't know whether I'd have been able to bring myself to pull her chip. At the very least, I'd have put the chip back in her head afterword, just like John did, so that scene was so believable for me. It's exactly what I'd have done. Great episode.

Do you find this valuable?    
SurfingEagle
SurfingEagle
168. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 8:40 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 8:40 PM EDT
"Lol, that boy staring up at Cameron and the other female Terminator was so funny, and you're right, that fight was easily one of the better ones. There's nothing like watching Cameron dominate. I also really liked the fight in "Automatic for People" where Cameron and Sarah teamed up and took down the Greenway T-888. Sarah set him up, and Cameron came in with the take down. And while it's not exactly a fight, Cromartie's whole plan and its execution during "The Mousetrap" was masterfully done. He outsmarted Sarah and Derek there.

And "Samson and Delilah" easily ranks as my favorite, with the pilot coming in second. That one's got it all, action, tragedy, grief, excitement, anticipation, romance, and everything in between. Cameron's emotional outburst scene and John saving her after are easily my favorite scenes of the series. That was so freaky too; there's been a lot of times where I've tried putting myself in John's position there, and I seriously don't know whether I'd have been able to bring myself to pull her chip. At the very least, I'd have put the chip back in her head afterword, just like John did, so that scene was so believable for me. It's exactly what I'd have done. Great episode.

"
That's was the first time a terminator started to cry. I was like "why is she crying? there's no crying in terminator...there's no crying in terminator". I didn't even see the whole Jameron thing until then, and I was like "ohhhh, they must have been up to something in the future".

I would've pulled the chip. Had to. She just threw a wrench at his head like 30 sec prior.
Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
169. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 9:12 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 9:14 PM EDT
"That's was the first time a terminator started to cry. I was like "why is she crying? there's no crying in terminator...there's no crying in terminator". I didn't even see the whole Jameron thing until then, and I was like "ohhhh, they must have been up to something in the future".

I would've pulled the chip. Had to. She just threw a wrench at his head like 30 sec prior."
Yeah, I remember thinking something along the lines of, "Wow, she can cry?" followed by, "Damn, I don't think I could do it."

I picked up on Jameron around, well there was a few things in the pilot, but mainly the chip removal scene in S1. S2 really made me go down the "they must have been up to something in the future" road, what with the premier and all the references to how close they are in the future, and the kind of relationship they Cameron hinted that they had.

And well..., yeah, you're absolutely right, pulling her chip was the logical choice; I'm just too much of a softy I guess lol. And then there's that whole guy/girl interaction. A lot of guys, me included, have an aversion to even the idea of hurting girls, so that again would worked against me. I guess that's why I'm not the future savior of mankind though lol.
Do you find this valuable?    
SurfingEagle
SurfingEagle
170. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 10:10 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 10:10 PM EDT
"Yeah, I remember thinking something along the lines of, "Wow, she can cry?" followed by, "Damn, I don't think I could do it."

I picked up on Jameron around, well there was a few things in the pilot, but mainly the chip removal scene in S1. S2 really made me go down the "they must have been up to something in the future" road, what with the premier and all the references to how close they are in the future, and the kind of relationship they Cameron hinted that they had.

And well..., yeah, you're absolutely right, pulling her chip was the logical choice; I'm just too much of a softy I guess lol. And then there's that whole guy/girl interaction. A lot of guys, me included, have an aversion to even the idea of hurting girls, so that again would worked against me. I guess that's why I'm not the future savior of mankind though lol."
It's a stretch for me to imagine that I would be in a real situation like that. But if I were hypothetically in that situation, then she would really be a machine and not a real girl. So pulling the chip wouldn't be hurting a girl. Also, I know that I could put the chip back. So, I'm not really killing her. Not sure what I would do about returning the chip. Can't decide whether I would take the chance.
Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
171. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 10:44 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 10:44 PM EDT
"It's a stretch for me to imagine that I would be in a real situation like that. But if I were hypothetically in that situation, then she would really be a machine and not a real girl. So pulling the chip wouldn't be hurting a girl. Also, I know that I could put the chip back. So, I'm not really killing her. Not sure what I would do about returning the chip. Can't decide whether I would take the chance."
Lol, playing with hypothetical situations is something I just love to do, cause of course nothing like this would ever really happen, well probably not.

Good points, though the fact that she looks and acts like a girl would still mess with my head a lot. True, intellectually speaking, I would know immediatley that she's really a machine, and I can just as easily put the chip back in. But instinctively, my gut reactions would still probably be to respond to her like she was girl, especially after her performance. I don't know what I'd do. I really don't know.

Of course, On the flip side, you'd certainly live to see another day, while I only might live to see another day, so yours is definitely the smarter choice. Mine is the emotional response, yours is the rational one. You're Spock and I'm McCoy here lol.
Do you find this valuable?    
SurfingEagle
SurfingEagle
172. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 10:56 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 10:56 PM EDT
"Lol, playing with hypothetical situations is something I just love to do, cause of course nothing like this would ever really happen, well probably not.

Good points, though the fact that she looks and acts like a girl would still mess with my head a lot. True, intellectually speaking, I would know immediatley that she's really a machine, and I can just as easily put the chip back in. But instinctively, my gut reactions would still probably be to respond to her like she was girl, especially after her performance. I don't know what I'd do. I really don't know.

Of course, On the flip side, you'd certainly live to see another day, while I only might live to see another day, so yours is definitely the smarter choice. Mine is the emotional response, yours is the rational one. You're Spock and I'm McCoy here lol. "
lol, I guess I do resemble Mr. Spock thinking in this situation. But even in real life, I'm not overly effected by a woman crying because half the time they're just doing it to get their way or get out of trouble or make you feel guilty.

It's like Jeff Foxworthy once roughly said. How many times have you seen a guy running along crying and a woman chasing after him saying I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I didn't mean it.
Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
173. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 11:05 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 11:05 PM EDT
"lol, I guess I do resemble Mr. Spock thinking in this situation. But even in real life, I'm not overly effected by a woman crying because half the time they're just doing it to get their way or get out of trouble or make you feel guilty.

It's like Jeff Foxworthy once roughly said. How many times have you seen a guy running along crying and a woman chasing after him saying I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I didn't mean it."
Lol, you're supposed to say, "Really Doctor McCoy, you must learn to govern your passions; they will be your undoing." Of course, why do think it's so effective? A lot of guys end up being susceptible to it, Lol. Doesn't mean we're smart, of course, but hey, if it works, they use use it.

If only guys could find some way of doing the same to women...
Do you find this valuable?    
SurfingEagle
SurfingEagle
174. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 11 2009, 11:37 PM EDT | Post edited: Jun 11 2009, 11:37 PM EDT
"If only guys could find some way of doing the same to women... "
I have no ideas...

I would think Spock would throw in a condescending remark like "Dr McCoy, your reaction is truly illogical which is entirely what I would expect coming from an erratic emotional human such as yourself"
Do you find this valuable?    
Hyperalloy
Hyperalloy
175. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jun 12 2009, 1:22 AM EDT | Post edited: Jun 12 2009, 1:26 AM EDT
"I have no ideas...

I would think Spock would throw in a condescending remark like "Dr McCoy, your reaction is truly illogical which is entirely what I would expect coming from an erratic emotional human such as yourself""
Lol, neither do I. And so the status quo continues...

And McCoy responds with, "Exactly you pointed-eared hob goblin! Now put away your butcher knives and let me save this girl... cyborg, whatever the hell she is!"

Nice Spock improvisation, by the way. I just grabbed a random quote from Star Trek 2 for my Spock lol.
Do you find this valuable?    
lordpoee
lordpoee
176. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jul 4 2009, 3:20 PM EDT | Post edited: Jul 4 2009, 3:20 PM EDT
Never has a more realistic death been portrayed on public television, nor how quickly a fire-fight can go "wrong". In the midst of a firefight, in one split second you can simply be dead.

While I am fond of the character "Derek', (because the actor who portrays him seems to really bring him to life and put you in contact with the burden he carries, perhaps more so than John or Sarah because he HAS SEEN the horror that awaits if they fail.) I also find portrayal of his death befitting soldier; so to you I say "Hooah" !

But in a story revolving around time-travel, Derek's return is all but inevitable.
Do you find this valuable?    
Ban_D
Ban_D
177. RE: Toni Graphia on Derek's Death
Jul 15 2009, 3:33 AM EDT | Post edited: Jul 15 2009, 3:33 AM EDT
"I always shake my head when I see them walking around with 9mm's. Seriously, they might as well be firing water guns if you're talking Terminators. 9mm can be stopped with half-decent body armor let alone a Terminator's hyperalloy combat chassis. Really no handgun will do, well anything, to a Terminator, but .40 to .45 caliber rounds would have been a lot more believable. In the pilot, when Cromartie scanned the SWAT team's weapons, most of them were carrying MP5's, which fire 9mm rounds. He classified them as having zero threat level lol."

The funny thing is that even Derek himself previously was running around with an M79 or whatever grenade launcher - the same kind Arnold's T800 character had in T2 movie. That could really do the job (or at least 'make it consider its life choices' :-D).
(Although use such kind of weapon in closed area - like he prepares to do in the desert law-firm office Cromartie keeps Charlie's wife - is more than hazardous in real life of course - but this is a show fortunately.)
Also the big sniper rifle he used at the military high school would do.

About SWAT team MP5-s - i think Cromartie decided as no threat since they kept their guns low, not even aiming on him.
(In S1 last episode he kills the whole band with MP5-s equipped anyway, since they fire on him.)
Even if the endo is so strong, the 'skin' can have serious damage from.
Do you find this valuable?    
First < Previous | 6 7 8 9

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)